Sonic the Hedgehog (Live Action Fan Film)

I'm just curious to know, despite knowing that they poured every dime they could into this project, especially with their limited resources, why do you guys give it the low opinion you have for it? Why don't you kinda give an "A for effort" or "Not bad given their resources, but could have done better"?

Originally Posted by Zero Gravity I'm just curious to know, despite knowing that they poured every dime they could into this project, especially with their limited resources, why do you guys give it the low opinion you have for it? Why don't you kinda give an "A for effort" or "Not bad given their resources, but could have done better"?

Just because it's a fan project doesn't give it an "A" for greatness. I also extremely dislike the Sailor Moon live action project that was recently done. Most of the things in the fan film, from what I remember, looked off. As in they met something called the uncanny valley. It looks creepy, off putting, and you can't sympathize with something that looks like that.

If it looks obviously fake then it feels B-movie fake, it comes off cheesy.