Anime diverges from Manga

[Bonediddly]

Originally Posted by EagleEyes But there are some cases such as Air gear when the anime is ALOT better than the manga even though it doesn't follow the entire story.

The manga must be really bad, in that case.

Full Metal Alchemist was awesome despite diverging from the manga (which I haven't read...).

[EagleEyes]

Originally Posted by Bonediddly The manga must be really bad, in that case. Full Metal Alchemist was awesome despite diverging from the manga (which I haven't read...).

You insulted Air Gear............

Im sorry Bones, I now have to break your legs :(

[Shadows_Revenge]

Originally Posted by Bonediddly The manga must be really bad, in that case. Full Metal Alchemist was awesome despite diverging from the manga (which I haven't read...).

but now they are going back and re-doing it... it just doesnt make sense to me that they couldnt of waited for the manga to finish to start the anime series. Also the reason the original anime was so go was because the creator had full power over its direction. So the original anime seemed smooth, but then the creator wanted something different for the manga

[Oni]

Originally Posted by Shadows_Revenge but now they are going back and re-doing it... it just doesnt make sense to me that they couldnt of waited for the manga to finish to start the anime series. Also the reason the original anime was so go was because the creator had full power over its direction. So the original anime seemed smooth, but then the creator wanted something different for the manga

It has to do purely with the popularity of the manga at the time.

Also, you make it seem like every manga-ka is a genius that can totally direct an anime to perfection. I call BS on this.