Signature Critique Thread

[Rhetorical Gamer]

10/10 All awesome pokemon especially Milotic!!!!!!!!!!! :D

8/10 i like the master chief and also
i still dont see what has been done there

[deadlymustach50]

STREET FIGHTER! 8/10

Oh so Epic 10/10 brill

[Shidohari]

THAT IS AWESOMESAWCE

I see no sig here. Or are you being minimalist?

2/10 (only for being brave enough to post in sig critique thread but have no personalised sig)

Anyway, I want to maybe add some more to mine. What do you suggest?

I should probably make a note that we have a "Rate A Signature" thread in forum games. This one is for more in-depth stuff like how people go certain effects, etc. So ratings aren't really necessary to get your point across.

In relation Deadly's signature makes me lol and Jessi's signature breaks the size limitation rules. Please change it.

[Kibs]

Kana's sig is pretty awesome, with all that cutting and whatnot

[Kate]

Kibs, unless people think you're a boy from your username, you're gonna have a problem there. Love the signature, though. Anime Bites is nommingly good!

I think Kibs is looking for that, but Toa looks awesome in that image. I would've liked to see another angle of her or a different stock, but it's pretty win.

[EagleEyes]

Kibs, it is so purty

Kana's:

EE's:

Kib's:

Deadly's:

9/10 Its what I imagine Jubi does offline

Originally Posted by Zero Gravity 9/10 Its what I imagine Jubi does offline

Did you not see what Taigashimi literally posted just a few posts up?

Originally Posted by Kanashimi I should probably make a note that we have a "Rate A Signature" thread in forum games. This one is for more in-depth stuff like how people go certain effects, etc. So ratings aren't really necessary to get your point across.

Additionally, Kate's signature just screams "I'm awesome, look at me being awesome, I'm gonna go over here and be awesome", The lighting could be a bit lighter though.

I get the feeling that Amui likes Nel. I'm assuming she is a star ocean character

I get the feeling Xmas likes Smugleaf. I assume it is because he is so smug.

I will let you infer who "he" is in the sentence.

OMG Xmas wins everything! Smugleaf!!!!

Originally Posted by Amui Did you not see what Taigashimi literally posted just a few posts up?

No Ma'am I did NOT!

Originally Posted by Amui Additionally, Kate's signature just screams "I'm awesome, look at me being awesome, I'm gonna go over here and be awesome", The lighting could be a bit lighter though.

You're right, I never thought about that since I was going for high contrast. I hope some more stocks of this character come out so I can make something different, but gotta wait for Disgaea 4.