[Oni]

Just throwing out videos without attaching them to anything isn't proving anyone's point.

To be noted: You have gone from saying that AMVs are a sub-section of MADs,

I don't see why it wouldn't. AMVs are just a subset of MADs, so as long as it's noise (AMV's grown to be pretty broad) over anime I'd imagine it's fine. I mean I already posted two.

to saying that they ARE MADs,

Well I can't and I have. An AMV can't "be like a MAD" because they are MADs, so unless you can accept this we aren't gonna get anywhere.

And this is why I can't take you seriously. Your argument hasn't been able to stay on course the entire time. To me MADs and AMVs are two totally different ways of executing the music video, one done with stock footage on top of stock audio, the other being done in a much more complicated way.

So, no. I can't see your point, because your point keeps changing.