Signature Critique Thread
 

This thread is for people to critique other people's signatures.

Remember to be nice, and don't post without saying something about someone else's signature.

Re: Signature Critique Thread
 

Kana's signature makes me want to watch Sailor Moon Abridged.

Re: Signature Critique Thread
 

Kana's is actually really really good it's almost 3-d ish

Re: Signature Critique Thread
 

Thankies, I liked the idea... I just wish the water flow was longer so it could fade easier (luckily the forums has a blue background, lol).

Was yours done by The Scribbles? It reminds me of that style, cause I like how the stock is blurred but the background seems to use hard edged lines.

Re: Signature Critique Thread
 

yea kana's looks really good

Re: Signature Critique Thread
 

Yes mine was done by scribs I'm nowhere near as talented as she is.

Re: Signature Critique Thread
 

Kana's is pretty win.

Re: Signature Critique Thread
 

I like eagleeyes' and jubilee's, it must have taken them hours.

Re: Signature Critique Thread
 

Kibs...it is the epitome of beauty #ohdear

...and it only took like 2 hours ... :giggle:

Re: Signature Critique Thread
 

My word, the wolfs are everywhere xD Nicely done EE, Kibs and Jubi :P

Re: Signature Critique Thread
 

Redone mine. Thoughts?

Re: Signature Critique Thread
 

I can veritably say that this is the best signature you've made on our forums so far.

Re: Signature Critique Thread
 

alright just made this one what do yall think

Re: Signature Critique Thread
 

Alright. This is simple, but I think it works nicely.

Re: Signature Critique Thread
 

Im totally digging your sig Kibs #thumbup

Re: Signature Critique Thread
 

Yea. His is all animooted and stuff.

Re: Signature Critique Thread
 

Kibs and Llian's both look awesome. But then, Kibs made them so no surprise. :3 How's mine?

Re: Signature Critique Thread
 

I gots a new sig~
gona c-c-c-combo break you guys and not make it an anime, but what do you think?
and yours looks cool Lite~

Re: Signature Critique Thread
 

Kibs is easily the most win here, but Taigashimi comes in a close second.

Re: Signature Critique Thread
 

BANG BANG BANG BANG BANG

your set looks like win, I like it, though you could use some text, or something

Re: Signature Critique Thread
 

What can I say? Kibs obviously wins, but some of you have some pretty creative ones as well. Mine isn't extremely fancified, but it works for me just fine. #glorious

Re: Signature Critique Thread
 

We can never have enough Fuuko!!

Re: Signature Critique Thread
 

Thought I re-do mine before I pack for college.

Kibs and Llian your sprite work is so beautiful ;-;

Re: Signature Critique Thread
 

Oh Scribbles! :awesome:

I really like your new one...it is so pretty #pika

Re: Signature Critique Thread
 

It's a... very pink. The writing kinda sticks out a bit.

Re: Signature Critique Thread
 

Re: Signature Critique Thread
 

Dist: I like your style, but I feel that you overuse effects a bit. It's kinda like looking through a tinted window at everything.

Re: Signature Critique Thread
 

Yeah, when I usually finished them I feel as though I added a bit too much. For some reason when I make a sig I feel like I should add everything I have.

Re: Signature Critique Thread
 

I been posting alot of different signature.... I cant seem to pick the right one for me
I really like all of them, but the one I really like the most is Kanashimi and Kibs both are a very unique

Re: Signature Critique Thread
 

I like it! Creative!

Re: Signature Critique Thread
 

Nice work with the sig. Not too flashy, shows off your main six, keeping it simple. Good design and appropriate.

Re: Signature Critique Thread
 

Re: Signature Critique Thread
 

I like that fellow's sword...

And I think the background matches nicely

:awesome:

Re: Signature Critique Thread
 

meow meow meow :D

Re: Signature Critique Thread
 

Oh Soundbreaker
you sig is like ice cream to my eyes

Re: Signature Critique Thread
 

I think the background could use a lil more creativity :)

Re: Signature Critique Thread
 

I see nothing!!!! AAAAAHHHH IM BLIND!!!!!!!!!!!

Re: Signature Critique Thread
 

There is nothing wrong with this sig. Move along.

Re: Signature Critique Thread
 

Love the background don't know that character though! sorry :(

Re: Signature Critique Thread
 

I expect him to do something else after 1000 side thrusts