Signature Critique Thread

[Kanashimi]

This thread is for people to critique other people's signatures.

Remember to be nice, and don't post without saying something about someone else's signature.

[TheNinja4759]

Kana's signature makes me want to watch Sailor Moon Abridged.

[yugiboy360]

Kana's is actually really really good it's almost 3-d ish

[Kanashimi]

Thankies, I liked the idea... I just wish the water flow was longer so it could fade easier (luckily the forums has a blue background, lol).

Was yours done by The Scribbles? It reminds me of that style, cause I like how the stock is blurred but the background seems to use hard edged lines.

[Drago142222]

yea kana's looks really good

[yugiboy360]

Yes mine was done by scribs I'm nowhere near as talented as she is.

[EagleEyes]

Kana's is pretty win.

[Kibs]

I like eagleeyes' and jubilee's, it must have taken them hours.

[Jubilee]

Kibs...it is the epitome of beauty #ohdear

...and it only took like 2 hours ... :giggle:

[Lite]

My word, the wolfs are everywhere xD Nicely done EE, Kibs and Jubi :P

[TheNinja4759]

Redone mine. Thoughts?

[Kibs]

I can veritably say that this is the best signature you've made on our forums so far.

[grimdefeat]

alright just made this one what do yall think

[JinnRemona]

Alright. This is simple, but I think it works nicely.

[Dophanes "D!" Raosuke]

I can veritably say that this is the best signature you've made on our forums so far.

Im totally digging your sig Kibs #thumbup

[TheNinja4759]

Yea. His is all animooted and stuff.

[Lite]

Kibs and Llian's both look awesome. But then, Kibs made them so no surprise. :3 How's mine?

[Dophanes "D!" Raosuke]

I gots a new sig~
gona c-c-c-combo break you guys and not make it an anime, but what do you think?
and yours looks cool Lite~

[Amui]

Kibs is easily the most win here, but Taigashimi comes in a close second.

[Kibs]

BANG BANG BANG BANG BANG

your set looks like win, I like it, though you could use some text, or something

[twillÿ]

What can I say? Kibs obviously wins, but some of you have some pretty creative ones as well. Mine isn't extremely fancified, but it works for me just fine. #glorious

[Llian]

We can never have enough Fuuko!!

[TehScribbles]

Thought I re-do mine before I pack for college.

Kibs and Llian your sprite work is so beautiful ;-;

[Jubilee]

Oh Scribbles! :awesome:

I really like your new one...it is so pretty #pika

[Bonediddly]

It's a... very pink. The writing kinda sticks out a bit.

[Dist]

I actually have two signature I want some C&C on.

http://i33.tinypic.com/xc9oyg.jpg
http://i37.tinypic.com/2wlwqyp.jpg

(Second one has a name because I made it for someone, heh.)

[TheDrunkenShadow]

Dist: I like your style, but I feel that you overuse effects a bit. It's kinda like looking through a tinted window at everything.

[Dist]

Dist: I like your style, but I feel that you overuse effects a bit. It's kinda like looking through a tinted window at everything.

Yeah, when I usually finished them I feel as though I added a bit too much. For some reason when I make a sig I feel like I should add everything I have.

[ZshadowX]

I been posting alot of different signature.... I cant seem to pick the right one for me
I really like all of them, but the one I really like the most is Kanashimi and Kibs both are a very unique

[Zero Gravity]

I like it! Creative!

[SoulArbiter]

Nice work with the sig. Not too flashy, shows off your main six, keeping it simple. Good design and appropriate.

[soundbreaker]

Slayer is awesome, therefore your sig is awesome. I like the colours and the background too.

[Jubilee]

I like that fellow's sword...

And I think the background matches nicely

:awesome:

[Rhetorical Gamer]

meow meow meow :D

[ZshadowX]

Oh Soundbreaker
you sig is like ice cream to my eyes

[Cyrus]

I think the background could use a lil more creativity :)

[Rhetorical Gamer]

I see nothing!!!! AAAAAHHHH IM BLIND!!!!!!!!!!!

[Bonediddly]

There is nothing wrong with this sig. Move along.

[Rhetorical Gamer]

Love the background don't know that character though! sorry :(

[Zero Gravity]

I expect him to do something else after 1000 side thrusts

[ZshadowX]

IM a BIG FAN of Jubi Sig

like every month or so he changes his signature

~Awesome! ^~^

[Rhetorical Gamer]

i was the first 8 bit monkey before donkey kong

[grimdefeat]

its really sad po pi po happened to be on when i looked at this page and megaman is dancing like perfectly to it

[Stone]

Awesome siggy. Really like the wings and naturally...

DAT SLOGAN!

[Jubilee]

IM a BIG FAN of Jubi Sig

like every month or so he changes his signature

~Awesome! ^~^

#thumbup

I like Z's setups as well...Super-active forum setup changers unite!

[jessileo127]

I dont actually know the anime that Jubi's Sig shot is from but I will say it makes me smile everytime I see it ^.^

[SoulArbiter]

You get points for actually doing the signature yourself and bonus points for wishing everyone a Merry Christmas.

However, I'd advise you to use Photoshop next time.

[Bonediddly]

DOLPHINPUNCH/10
Srsly tho. That's pretty awesome.
My only criticism is that the dolphin looks kind of stiff.

[Kanashimi]

New siggy and avatar to represent Kana's Korner fans being dubbed prinnies. Had some fun with this for the most part, and thanks to Kibs for splicing my images. #geee

Love all the Christmas spirit signatures I've been seeing~

[Amui]

10/10 LIKE A BAWS!
Also that character looks sufficiently similar to Tenori Taiga.















But it could use more Bananas.

[ZshadowX]

Kana's avatar and sig just blew my mind!
A+/10 lol
~ plus prinny are always kewl dude

[Shidohari]

man all these signatures look great....i'm so jealous

[Rhetorical Gamer]

Where is yours?!?!?! :O

[grimdefeat]

just barely made this set to go along with my nametag

[Shidohari]

Where is yours?!?!?! :O

i don't have one and i am not skilled. also haven't purchased one yet.

[SoulArbiter]

Shadow's is pretty cool - and should I be ashamed I don't know what it's from? #ohdear

[jessileo127]

Although am not sure on what that character is but its totally epic ^.^
8/10 ^.^

[mahay]

Everything is in order except your BB code is showing :giggle:

Japanese dragons FTW indeed 8/10 (just fix that code)

[Mollybibbles]

9/10 Giant Luigi= Win

[Zero Gravity]

8/10 - Bananas....o_o

[Rhetorical Gamer]

10/10 All awesome pokemon especially Milotic!!!!!!!!!!! :D

[grimdefeat]

8/10 i like the master chief and also
i still dont see what has been done there

[deadlymustach50]

STREET FIGHTER! 8/10

[jessileo127]

Oh so Epic 10/10 brill

[Shidohari]

THAT IS AWESOMESAWCE

[mahay]

#pedo I see no sig here. Or are you being minimalist?

2/10 (only for being brave enough to post in sig critique thread but have no personalised sig)

Anyway, I want to maybe add some more to mine. What do you suggest?

[Kanashimi]

I should probably make a note that we have a "Rate A Signature" thread in forum games. This one is for more in-depth stuff like how people go certain effects, etc. So ratings aren't really necessary to get your point across.

In relation Deadly's signature makes me lol and Jessi's signature breaks the size limitation rules. Please change it.

[Kibs]

Kana's sig is pretty awesome, with all that cutting and whatnot

[Kate]

Kibs, unless people think you're a boy from your username, you're gonna have a problem there. Love the signature, though. Anime Bites is nommingly good!

[Kanashimi]

I think Kibs is looking for that, but Toa looks awesome in that image. I would've liked to see another angle of her or a different stock, but it's pretty win.

[EagleEyes]

Kibs, it is so purty #shock

[Jubilee]

Kana's: #thumbup

EE's: :awesome:

Kib's: #ohdear

Deadly's: http://www.pixpow.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/10/amazed.gif

[Zero Gravity]

9/10 Its what I imagine Jubi does offline

[Amui]

9/10 Its what I imagine Jubi does offline

Did you not see what Taigashimi literally posted just a few posts up?

I should probably make a note that we have a "Rate A Signature" thread in forum games. This one is for more in-depth stuff like how people go certain effects, etc. So ratings aren't really necessary to get your point across.

Additionally, Kate's signature just screams "I'm awesome, look at me being awesome, I'm gonna go over here and be awesome", The lighting could be a bit lighter though.

[christmas4477]

I get the feeling that Amui likes Nel. I'm assuming she is a star ocean character

[Jubilee]

I get the feeling Xmas likes Smugleaf. I assume it is because he is so smug.

I will let you infer who "he" is in the sentence.

[Zero Gravity]

OMG Xmas wins everything! Smugleaf!!!! #glorious

Did you not see what Taigashimi literally posted just a few posts up?


No Ma'am I did NOT! #wut

[Kanashimi]

Additionally, Kate's signature just screams "I'm awesome, look at me being awesome, I'm gonna go over here and be awesome", The lighting could be a bit lighter though.

You're right, I never thought about that since I was going for high contrast. I hope some more stocks of this character come out so I can make something different, but gotta wait for Disgaea 4.